Right of Pre-emption

Pre-emption Case Judgment by Supreme Court

Landmark Pre-emption Case Judgment by Supreme Court

Right of Pre-emption Who, when, and how can use right of pre-emption? What is its legal status in today’s era? This term known is known as the Shufa in Urdu. The purpose of this law was to prevent outsiders from entering and purchasing land  where families and communities have lived together for generations. On which lands is this law not applicable? This law does not apply to inherited property, mainland acquired through gift, waqf property, or estate given by a husband to his wife as dower, etc. Crux the right of pre-empation law The right of Shufa is a legal right that allows a person to purchase estate before others. This right is granted to co-sharers, neighbors, and those who have a passage or waterway through the land.  To exercise this right, a person must declare their intention to purchase the land in the presence of two witnesses and send a legal notice to the buyer.  If the buyer refuses to sell, the person can file a lawsuit to claim their right. However, if they fail to file a claim within one year, their right of pre-emption will be lost. Right of Pre-emption case, the Supreme Court of Pakistan In tribunal, delivered a judgment that has far-reaching implications. The case, Civil Appeal No.795 of 2017, involved a dispute over the right of pre-emption under the Khy Pakhtunkhwa Pre-emption Act, 1987.   Parties: Kashmali Khan & others, versus Mst. Malala, the respondent. Legal Representation: Mr. Abdul Samad Khan represented the appellants, while Mr. Zia-ur-Rehman Khan and Syed Rifaqat Hussain Shah represented the respondent. Date of Hearing: 18.05.2023 Case Overview The case revolved around a area parcel in Mouza Hisra Barani Payan, Tehsil Tongi, measuring 100 kanals and 19 marlas. The dispute arose when the defendant purchased the land for Rs.500,000/-, triggering the appellants’ right of pre-emption.   Judgment The lower Court had initially ruled in favor of the appellants, recognizing their right to preemption the sale. However, on the defendant’s revision application, the High Court overturned the decision, leading to the appeal in the Supreme Court. The summry of the matter lay in the appellants’ compliance with the preemption requirements, particularly regarding the demands or “Talbs” necessary for pre-emption exercise. While the appellants successfully proved their Talb-i-Muwathibat, they faltered in fulfilling the formalities of Talb-i-Ishhad.   Legal Observations The Supreme Court emphasized the meticulous adherence to  procedures, highlighting the importance of disclosing witness names for Talb-i-Ishhad. The omission of this crucial information, combined with other deficiencies in the appellants’ actions, led to the dismissal of their claim.   Contact us for more Information In a rigorous application of pre-emption laws, the Supreme tribunal ultimately dismissed the appeal, underscoring the stringent nature of pre-emption rights. The judgment serves as a precedent in shufa cases, setting a benchmark for legal compliance and procedural conformity. In a landmark ruling by the Supreme Court, this preemption case highlights the significance of procedural diligence in upholding legal rights and obligations. The PDF for the full citation is below for reference 24Justice Pre-empation 795 SC 2017 Our panel of skilled Lawyers in Pakistan specializes in shufa cases in Pakistan and offers personalized advice and robust lawful solutions. AI Legal Site: For general information, visit 24Justice.com – Pakistan’s First Legal AI Site. Personalized Assistance: For more specific queries or legal representation, reach out to us: Call: 0092 308 5510031 WhatsApp: 0092 308 5510031 Contact Form: Prefer writing? Fill out our contact form below, and we’ll respond promptly.   [wpforms id=”4658″]

Landmark Pre-emption Case Judgment by Supreme Court Read More »

Information, , ,
THE PUNJAB PRE-EMPTION ACT 1991 (Pb. Act IX of 1991)

THE PUNJAB PRE-EMPTION ACT 1991 (Pb. Act IX of 1991)

THE PUNJAB PRE-EMPTION ACT 1991 (Pb. Act IX of 1991)   The Punjab Pre-emption Act, 1991, holds a pivotal role in regulating land transactions in the Punjab province of Pakistan. This act provides a legal mechanism for preempting or purchasing certain properties before they are sold to someone else. Its primary objective is to maintain the social fabric of rural communities by preventing the fragmentation of agricultural land and ensuring that it remains with the existing landowners or co-sharers. The Punjab Pre-emption Act, 1991, serves as a significant legal framework for property transactions in the province. C O N T E N T S Sections Short title, extent and commencement. Definitions. Interpretation. Act to override other laws. Right of pre-emption. Persons in whom the right of pre-emption vests. Priorities in the right of pre-emption. Joint right of pre-emption how exercised. Method of distribution of the property where more than one persons are equally entitled. Withdrawal of claim. Sale of appurtenances of land. Right to revoke sale. Demand of pre-emption. Demand by guardian or agent. Waiver of the right of pre-emption. Death of pre-emptor. Abatement of right of pre-emption. Exercise of right of pre-emption by a Muslim and a non-Muslim against each other. Right of pre-emption non-transferable and indivisible. Where the pre-emptor and vendee equally entitled. Improvements made by the vendee. Improvement made in the status of the vendee-defendant after institution of the Suit. No right of pre-emption in respect of certain properties. Plaintiff to deposit sale price of the property. Deposit or refund of excess price. Sum deposited by pre-emptor not to be attached. Determination of price. Market value how to be determined. Government may exclude areas from pre-emption. Limitation. Notice. Matters ancillary or akin to the provisions of this Act. Application of the Civil Procedure Code and Qanun-e-Shahadat Order. Repeal of Act I of 1913. Saving. Rules. Repeal of Ordinance IX of 1991.   THE PUNJAB PRE-EMPTION ACT 1991 (Pb. Act IX of 1991) [6 April 1991] An Act to bring in conformity with the injunctions of Islam the law relating to pre-emption Preamble.— Whereas it is expedient to re-enact the existing law relating to pre-emption, so as to bring it in conformity with the injunctions of Islam as set out in the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah;       It is hereby enacted as follows:- Short title, extent and commencement.— (1) This Act may be called the Punjab Pre-emption Act 1991.       (2)  It extends to the whole of the Punjab.       (3)  It shall come into force at once. Definitions.— In this Act, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context—       (a)  “immovable property” means immovable property situated in any area other than an urban area or within cantonment limits as declared by any law relating to Local Bodies or Cantonments, as the case may be, for the time being in force;       (b)  “pre-emptor” means a person who has the right of pre-emption;       (c)  “right of pre-emption” means a right to acquire by purchase an immovable property in preference to other persons by reason of such right; and       (d)  “sale” means permanent transfer of the ownership of an immovable property in exchange for a valuable consideration and includes transfer of an immovable property by way of ‘hiba bil-iwaz’ or ‘hiba ba-shart-ul-iwaz’, but does not include—                (i)  transfer of an immovable property through inheritance or will or gift, other than ‘hiba bil-iwaz’ or ‘hiba ba-shart-ul-iwaz’;               (ii)  a sale in execution of a decree for money or of any order of a civil, criminal, revenue or any other court or a Revenue Officer or any local authority;              (iii)  exchange of agricultural land; and              (iv)  transfer of an immovable property for a consideration other than valuable consideration, such as the transfer of an immovable property by way of dower or composition in a murder or hurt case. Interpretation.— In the interpretation and the application of the provisions of this Act, the Court shall seek guidance from the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah. Act to override other laws.— The provisions of this Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything in any other law for the time being in force. Right of pre-emption.— The right of pre-emption shall arise in case of sale of immovable property. Persons in whom the right of pre-emption vests.— (1) The right of pre-emption shall vest—       (a)  firstly, in Shafi Sharik;       (b)  secondly, in Shafi Khalit; and       (c)  thirdly, in Shafi Jar.       Explanation.— I ‘Shafi Sharik’ means a person who is a co-owner in the corpus of the undivided immovable property sold.         II  ‘Shafi Khalit’ means a participator in the special rights attached to the immovable property sold, such as right of passage, right of passage of water or right of irrigation.        III  ‘Shafi Jar’ means a person who has a right of pre-emption because of owning an immovable property adjacent to the immovable property sold.       (2)  Notwithstanding anything in sub-section (1), the right of pre-emption shall be exercisable only in case of ‘Zaroorat’ or to avoid ‘Zarar’. Priorities in the right of pre-emption.— Where there are more than one participators in the special rights attached to the immovable property sold, the person having a special right shall have precedence over a person having a general right. ILLUSTRATIONS I)  A garden is irrigated by a water course which opens from a small canal. If this garden is sold, the person having right of irrigation from the water course shall have precedence over a person having right of irrigation from the canal. But if such garden is irrigated from the small canal, the person having right of irrigation from the water course as well as the person having right of irrigation from the canal shall have the right of pre-emption. II)  Where there are more than one pre-emptors and one has right of passage and the other has right of passage of water attached to the immovable property sold, the person having right of

THE PUNJAB PRE-EMPTION ACT 1991 (Pb. Act IX of 1991) Read More »

Laws of Pakistan - Library, , , , , , ,
Scroll to Top